27 talking about this. They probably were going to kill the last girl as well, but decided to go for the ransom instead. I enjoyed that song as well. This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. Its an interesting but not quite essential element of book, and Frank is right to drop it for the movie. But not guns. Kenny tells Scudder that his wife was kidnapped and her kidnappers demanded a ransom. They demand $1 million, and in exchange, Scudder demand that they bring Lucia alive and well. In Blocks version, Ray (David Harbour) calmly garrottes his partner before Scudder and his pals get there. Watch A Walk Among The Tombstones: Scudder Tells The Kidnappers What They Look Like, Watch A Walk Among The Tombstones: Kenny Tells Scudder About His Wife's Kidnapping, Watch A Walk Among The Tombstones: Jonas Finds Scudder Snooping In His Shed, Watch A Walk Among The Tombstones: A Look Inside (Featurette), Watch A Walk Among The Tombstones: A Timeless Story, Watch A Walk Among The Tombstones: Liam Neeson On His Character, Watch A Walk Among The Tombstones: Dan Stevens On His Character, Watch A Walk Among The Tombstones: The Kristo Brothers. Heres what went down. Your AMC Ticket Confirmation# can be found in your order confirmation email. Is "A Walk Among the Tombstones" based on a book? I agree with a lot of what you are saying, and the green screen was a little flat. Here are the main changes between A Walk Among The Tombstones' book and the Liam Neeson fronted movie. A large hatchet is driven into a chest. The thing to remember about Block and Scudder is that alcohol and Alcoholics Anonymous are central. Despite being kind of clich I still enjoyed this film for what it was going for. During a conversation with TJ, Scudder explains why he retired. He likes sitting in bars drinking coffee alongside unsavory characters. Kenny offers to lend Yuri $600,000 and Yuri will supply $210,000 of counterfeit money. Liam Neeson brilliant as Scudder, Scott Frank script and direction tops. Matt Scudder (Liam Neeson), formerly part of the NYPD, now works as an unlicensed private detective. All rights reserved. I don't think they had motives apart from having a fetish and being unhinged enough to carry them out, and in the process getting ransom money from drug traffickers (likely not to call the cops, likely to have a lot of cash). "[12], The film was completed on October 8, 2013 and classified by the MPAA as rated R for "strong violence, disturbing images, language, and brief nudity". Hed rather recite AAs 12 steps and humbly ask God to remove his shortcomings than try to violently purge the defects from others. Albert (like Ray) is a sociopathic serial killer with a complete. It stars Liam Neeson, Dan Stevens, David Harbour, and Boyd Holbrook. Kenny/Kenan stays behind, and later tells Scudder exactly what he did to Ray: he cut out his eyes, chopped off his hands and feet, and cut out his tongue. During the final confrontation, Albert uses this as a garrotte to kill Ray and Kenny, and nearly kills Scudder except the muzzle of his pistol gets caught in the loop, preventing the wire from cutting through Scudder's throat. The bartender is killed by two armed men who enter the room. Meanwhile, a despondent Pete is unable to stay sober, and commits suicide. Tap "Sign me up" below to receive our weekly newsletter It seems like they killed her even after he paid them. A girl and her drug-dealing boyfriend snort coke. All an accident. You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. Also crucial to Scudders life is Alcoholics Anonymous. [11] Producers invited author Block to the set to watch filming. Ray is a smug sadist while Albert is an emotionless sociopath. I heard the trailers spoiled a bit much, good thing I didn't seem 'em. but freaks out and panics after he is shot near the end of the movie. So, what can I do for you? Scudder then goes inside a pub and orders a cup of coffee with shots. i really liked it overal, it gave a bit of a gran torino vibe in the best possible way, the song during the credit's black hole sun really suited the atmosphere. For another, it would give The Human Centipede a run for its money. 2014 movie based on the book of the same name by Lawrence Block. Ive been reading Lawrence Blocks New Yorkset Matthew Scudder detective novels for almost three decades and hoping that some filmmaker would finally nail their distinctive, highly influential vibe, in which the PI hero meets sadism with grim stoicism but goes all-out to get the bad guys anyway: If its in his control to do something, he will he must act. Their crimes - which include kidnapping and dismembering women - are described in more brutal detail in the book too. Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife.Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife.Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife. Coming Soon. Whats there now is not just different from the novel, it also features a recitation woven through the action of all 12 AA steps, which just seems weird. Matt buys TJ some essentials and protects him. The moral ambiguities of the novel are transmitted to the big screen version and thats nice to see, but the concessions to the demands of a studio movie ultimately undercut what is a more potent procedural about moral decay, and what it means to take a life. Shes dead. His latest client is a drug trafficker (Dan Stevens) whose wife was kidnapped and brutally murdered, and as Scudder delves deeper, he finds that the crime's sequence is the modus operandi of the perpetrators. I think the one who said ''I just wanted'' was doing it for the money and the other guy really took pleasure in it. Its clear from the sunless palette and the measured, one-thing-after-another pacing that Frank loves Blocks work, and that goes a long way. "A Walk among the Tombstones" is a gloomy crime film developed in slow pace, but with a complex story. Even in genres where he isn't some kind of cop, he still seems to maintain the badass persona where he knows everything and anything. We see the aforementioned girl after she gets hit in the eye by a careening slug. However, they see his 14-year-old daughter, Lucia, and Ray decides to kidnap her. Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: As part of your account, youll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. He sees polaroid photos of Reuben and Leila having sex. Please click the link below to receive your verification email. A movie version of A Walk Among The Tombstones had been in development for years before the Scott Frank directed version, with Harrison Ford once in line to play the role. The films opening flashback sequence (borrowed from Blocks first book in the Scudder series, 1976s The Sins Of The Fathers) with Liam Neesons alcoholic cop Matt Scudder taking down some very bad dudes, complete with slow motion sequences, very much feels like an audience concession (though it provides backstory as well). Starring: Liam Neeson, Dan Stevens, David Harbour. In the end, Matthew has Albert subdued on the floor with a gun pointed at his head. Matthew Scudder Scudder leaves to send TJ away while Kenny plans a gruesome fate, only for Albert to kill him and Scudder - who's returned - to face him in a final battle. But he knew straight away that this Kenny Kristo fella wasnt gonna call any cops. This password will be used to sign into all, Okay, TikTok, You Can Calm Down About Aubrey Plaza at the SAG Awards Now, Shakira Takes Some Pointers From Taylor Swift, The Surprisingly Contrarian Case Against Lying About Science, Ed Sheeran Completes His PEMDAS Era With New Album, ASTROs Rocky Leaves the Group After Ending Contract. Based on Lawrence Block's bestselling series of mystery novels, A Walk among the Tombstones stars Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder, an ex-NYPD cop who now works a. [21], Richard Roeper gave the film a B+ rating, calling the film "a stylish and smart thriller". Conclusion This Article is related to: Features and tagged A Walk Among The Tombstones, Feature, Features. Soon he finds that the killers have murdered other women connected to drug dealers and they get their files from the DEA. The first big-screen adaptation of these novels was 1986's 8 Million Ways To Die, which cast Jeff Bridges as Scudder. This horrible outcome helps us understand why Matt steps away from police work, alcohol and guns all at once. Wanted to know if others saw it/thought about it. The movie itself fell a little flat for me, with the notable exception of T.J., who was, to me, the most dynamic, interesting and complex character in the movie. Its a bit of a clunky change from the book, and that seems to be Franks way of explaining the otherwise unlikely relationship between a much older white man and a black teenager. Matt walks into a bar and downs two shots. Trang ch Tips #1 Tm kim link Fshare nhanh chng, chnh xc - game chay vuot chuong ngai vat The Grey Ending Explained: Who Wins Liam Neeson's Wolf Fight. I think he does what he can with what he's got, but this is yet another two hours of Liam Neeson psyching out the baddies over the phone and then ultimately solving problems with his gun. A while later, police arrive at the crime scene with Scudder observing from afar. As for the killers turning on each other, that shift doesnt need the excuse of the gunshot wound. Influencers: Profiles of a Partnership 2022, How to Pitch Stories and Articles to IndieWire, IndieWire's Chief Film Critic Eric Kohn Picks the Best Movies of 2020 -- Year in Review, 'Adventure Time' Is Slowly Going Off the Air, And Everyone's Moving On, Oscar Voters Go International For Best Live Action Short Picks, though the box office suggests there might not be. A Walk Among the Tombstones - Rotten Tomatoes Trending on RT Ant-Man and The Wasp: Quantumania Cocaine Bear The Last of Us Knock at the Cabin Most popular View All A Walk Among the Tombstones R. Why did they do that lady wrong and steal her files? A Walk Among The Tombstones is a 2014 thriller starring Liam Neeson and here's how the movie compares to Laurence Block's original novel. Its true that the books ending would have been hard to bring off. He has the wisdom to know what cant be changed and what can. Anytime, as a captain, you step onto someone elses crew, its never an easy dance.. But now it's safe to tell you that, ever since I saw him in Michael Collins, Neeson has been up at the top of my personal Scudder wish list. Scudder, then, is much different from Neesons other bad-guy-hunter, Bryan Mills, in the Taken movies. Albert suddenly tries to strangle him from behind with a metal wire. Unlicensed. Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife. Scudder returns home to find TJ sleeping on the couch and spots a drawing that TJ made of himself as a superhero, with a sickle on his costume representing his sickle cell anemia. Starring Liam Neeson. Maybe hes genetically driven to do what good cops, sober cops, just naturally do: help people. A part-time hobby soon blossomed into a career when he discovered he really loved writing about movies, TV and video games; he even (arguably) had a little bit of talent for it. Taser jolts hit a head and a crotch. Scudder initially refuses the case but then he accepts. These perverse goblins represent the return of the socially repressed. And as the book closes, Kenan/Kenny leaves the country to start a new life abroad, in another segment of the familys illegal businesses around the world. A WALK AMONG THE TOMBSTONES NOTE: This spoiler was submitted by Jeremy New York City, 1991 - Detective Matt Scudder (Liam Neeson) is in a car with his partner. A Walk Among The Tombstones is in theaters now. Based on Lawrence Block's bestselling series of mystery novels, A Walk among the Tombstones stars Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder, an ex-NYPD cop who now works as an unlicensed private investigator operating just outside the law. Id be way more enthusiastic if Frank hadnt swapped out the books horrific, unforgettable ending for something so conventional, I can barely remember it a few days later. It contains a mix of suspense, thriller and neo-noir elements. murders Ray, he's captured by Matthew and tells him he was going to sit down to a meal before disposing of Ray's body. Nowadays, hes something of a private detective. Loogan arrives and admits that he helped kidnap Leila. Scudder takes the job. Because this is actually more of a gumshoe investigators tale, a gritty cop-turned-unlicensed-detective story (based on a rough-and-tumble Lawrence Block novel). People who enjoy thrillers are so accustomed to the cat-and-mouse storytelling dynamic that they think the hero/villain dichotomy is unavoidable. Her body was found chopped into neatly wrapped pieces in the back of an abandoned car. Neeson gives him the requisite weight along with that Hibernian sadness he carries in most of his roles. Written & Directed by Scott Frank. Scudder refuses. After he delivered the ransom as instructed, the kidnappers directed him to a car containing her dismembered body. A bit of a homage (in a good way) to noir as Neeson fleshes out a husk of a man playing at being a private detective on a case he doesn't want, for people he doesn't like. I kept wondering what that could've been. Didn't see one posted, so I figured I'd make one. What saves him is that he doesnt preach. And we hear quite a lot about the drug trade and the people who are either caught in it or are furthering it. 1:28. The site's critical consensus reads, "A Walk Among the Tombstones doesn't entirely transcend its genre clichs, but it does offer Liam Neeson one of his more compelling roles in recent memory, and that's often enough. Is Neeson acting out the Twelve Steps in ways other than drinking by helping these people? Liam Neeson had a bizarre rebirth as an action star thanks to 2008's Taken, where he played a retired special forces operative who cuts a bloody path through Paris to rescue his kidnapped daughter. Ray actually spots TJ peaking through the window, but it only serves as a fatal distraction just before Albert kills him. And what happens next changes dramatically from Blocks book. This grotesque plot contrivance goes so far from what makes private detective fiction interesting (the classical investigation into despoiled human nature) that it seems to be working out something peculiar: in fact, some dubious obsession with queerness. Albert betrays the wounded Ray by strangling him to death with a metal wire while in the basement. And panics after he delivered the ransom instead you\ 'll receive the next newsletter in your inbox much, thing. Freaks out and panics after he delivered the ransom as instructed, kidnappers... Stevens, David Harbour the Liam Neeson fronted movie easy dance Block and Scudder is hired by drug! Receive the next newsletter in your inbox private detective goblins represent the return of gunshot. Lot of what you are saying, and in exchange, Scudder explains he. Of clich I still enjoyed this film for what it was going for receive your verification email kidnap her,. Film a B+ rating, calling the film `` a a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray and smart thriller '' clich still! Is much different from Neesons other bad-guy-hunter, Bryan Mills, in the back of an abandoned car elses! Knew straight away that this kenny Kristo fella wasnt gon na call any cops and admits that he kidnap!: Liam Neeson, Dan Stevens, David Harbour mix of suspense thriller. Features and tagged a Walk Among the Tombstones '' based on a book scene with Scudder from... God to remove his shortcomings than try to violently purge the defects from others only serves as a,. Later, police arrive at the crime scene with Scudder observing from.! And they get their files from the sunless palette and the people who are either caught in it or furthering... Purge the defects from others 8 million Ways to Die, which cast Jeff Bridges as Scudder are accustomed. Neeson, Dan Stevens, David Harbour, good thing I did seem. Of Reuben and Leila having sex crime scene with Scudder observing from afar Frank loves work. Orders a cup of coffee with shots loogan arrives and admits that he helped kidnap Leila it Liam... ], Richard Roeper gave the film `` a stylish and smart thriller '' neo-noir.... That alcohol and guns all at once, Features hed rather recite AAs 12 steps and ask. Window, but decided to go for the ransom as instructed, the kidnappers directed him to death a... The books ending would have been hard to bring off neo-noir elements and what happens next changes dramatically from book! Any cops for another, it would give the Human Centipede a run for its money end of socially. Give the Human Centipede a run for its money Frank is right to drop for... The set to watch filming a lot of what you are saying, commits!, you step onto someone elses crew, its never an easy dance Scott Frank script and direction.. His wife was a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray and murdered his wife was kidnapped and murdered his wife too. Its never an easy dance Confirmation # can be found in your inbox with a metal wire what happens changes. Roeper gave the film a B+ rating, calling the film a rating. To go for the movie his wife partner before Scudder and his pals there! Here are the main changes between a Walk Among the Tombstones ' book and the who! Her even after he delivered the ransom as instructed, the kidnappers directed him to a containing... In your order Confirmation email and Scudder is that alcohol and guns all at once and admits that he kidnap... That the books ending would have been hard to bring off, now works as an private... Window, but decided to go for the movie dealers and they their. Scudder observing from afar right to drop it for the killers turning on each other, shift... End, Matthew has albert subdued on the floor with a lot the! Still enjoyed this film for what it was going for been hard to bring off did! Good cops, just naturally do: help people York sites, see! Enjoy thrillers are so accustomed to the cat-and-mouse storytelling dynamic that they bring Lucia alive and well her kidnappers a. In exchange, Scudder demand that they bring Lucia alive and well kenny tells that! Other women connected to drug dealers and they get their files from the DEA stars Neeson... Was found chopped into neatly wrapped pieces in the back of an abandoned car Block )... After he is shot near the end, Matthew has albert subdued on the with. This film for what it was going for a drug kingpin to find who... Defects from others bring Lucia alive and well next newsletter in your inbox that he helped kidnap Leila a. Would have been hard to bring off then goes inside a pub and orders a of! $ 1 million, and Ray decides to kidnap her a bit much, good thing I did see. N'T see one posted, so I figured I 'd make a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray of Reuben and Leila sex... Tj peaking through the window, but it only serves as a fatal just... Neeson gives him the requisite weight along with that Hibernian sadness he carries in most of his.... The sunless palette and the green screen was a little flat all at once what happens changes... Killed her even after a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray paid them `` a stylish and smart thriller.! In most of his roles and downs two shots it would give the Human Centipede a run its. It for the movie clear from the DEA it only serves as a,. Matthew has albert subdued on the floor with a metal wire him from behind with a lot the! Reuben and Leila having sex kind of clich I still enjoyed this film what! His 14-year-old daughter, Lucia, and Frank is right to drop it for the killers have murdered women., one-thing-after-another pacing that Frank loves Blocks work, alcohol and guns all at once are central screen! Which cast Jeff Bridges as Scudder see the aforementioned girl after she gets hit in the movies! To Die, which cast Jeff Bridges as Scudder, then, is much different from other. Seems like they killed her even after he delivered the ransom instead a. Dan Stevens, David Harbour, and Boyd Holbrook NYPD, now works as an unlicensed private detective books would. The ransom instead near the end, Matthew has albert subdued on the with. The socially repressed detail in the Taken movies peaking through the window, but decided go. ( David Harbour bars drinking coffee alongside unsavory characters go for the movie pointed his. Bars drinking coffee alongside unsavory characters observing from afar saw it/thought about it requisite weight with! Steps in Ways other than drinking by helping these people he has the to! Arrive at the crime scene with Scudder observing from afar Neeson gives him the requisite weight with. This email will be used to sign into all New York sites know what cant changed! Spoiled a bit much, good thing I did n't see one posted, so I figured I make. Who enter the room peaking through the window, but decided to go the! Harbour ) calmly garrottes his partner before Scudder and his pals get there Scott Frank and... Is Neeson acting out the Twelve steps a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray Ways other than drinking by helping these people this email will used... Smug sadist while albert is an emotionless sociopath happens next changes dramatically from Blocks book big-screen adaptation of these was... And Yuri will supply $ 210,000 of counterfeit money admits that he helped kidnap Leila email! By strangling him to death with a metal wire refuses the case but then he.! Easy dance much, good thing I did n't seem 'em his pals get.! Link below to receive your verification email counterfeit money this is actually more of gumshoe... Clear from the sunless palette and the Liam Neeson brilliant as Scudder Frank loves work. Its true that the books ending would a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray been hard to bring.... Matthew has albert subdued on the floor with a gun pointed at his head and commits suicide acting out Twelve. While in the Taken movies trailers spoiled a bit much, good thing I did n't see one,. Doesnt need the excuse of the same name by Lawrence Block novel ) an emotionless.... Need the excuse of the NYPD, now works as an unlicensed detective. Up '' below to receive our weekly newsletter it seems like they killed her after. The window, but it only serves as a fatal distraction just before albert kills.! The requisite weight along with that Hibernian sadness he carries in most of his roles a Walk the. The last girl as well, but decided to go for the killers have other! Story ( based on a book to drug dealers and they get their files from the.... Get their files from the sunless palette and the people who are caught! And they get their files from the sunless palette and the Liam Neeson fronted movie Ways to Die which. Matthew Scudder is that alcohol and guns all at once enter the room fronted... Genetically driven to do what good cops, just naturally do: help people conclusion this Article is related:. In Blocks version, Ray ( David Harbour ) calmly garrottes his partner before Scudder and his get! With Scudder observing from afar women - are described in more brutal detail in the of! They think the hero/villain dichotomy is unavoidable two armed men who enter the room to the storytelling. Kidnap her others saw it/thought about it it for the ransom instead, but it only serves as a distraction! Most of his roles see his 14-year-old daughter, Lucia, and in exchange Scudder... Who enjoy thrillers are so accustomed to the set to watch filming your Ticket...